EDA.org Mantis
Mantis Bugtracker
Main | My View | View Issues | Docs | Wiki
  

Viewing Issue Simple Details [ Jump to Notes ] [ Wiki ] [ View Advanced ] [ Issue History ] [ Print ]
ID Category Severity Date Submitted Last Update
0000328 [SystemVerilog P1800] SV-BC feature 2004-11-29 20:27 2005-01-25 15:31
Reporter Brad Pierce View Status public  
Assigned To Stuart Sutherland
Priority normal Resolution fixed  
Status closed   Product Version
Summary 0000328: Keyword compatibility
Description In http://www.eda.org/sv-bc/hm/2499.html [^] , Stu
migrates ETF issue http://www.boyd.com/1364_btf/report/full_pr/287.html [^]
to SV-BC, proposing

   http://www.eda.org/sv-bc/hm/att-2499/P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal.pdf [^]

This proposal would add a new section 25.4 to the
SystemVerilog LRM to define new `keywords and `endkeywords
compiler directives.

Note that the new 'uwire' keyword needs to be added to each
of the tables in the proposal. Note also that the last paragraph should say "'interface' and 'endinterface'", and arguably 'interface' and 'endinterface' should not be bold in the last example.
Additional Information Version 2 approved non-unanimously by SV-BC on Nov. 30, 2004.
For: Stu, Brad, Doug, Don, Kathy
Opposed: Karen: (believes proposal is immature)
Abstain: steven: (working on 110, not much time to review)
         Mark: (awkward to use; would prefer stack instead of requiring
                    the directives in every file).
         Francoise: Unsure of utility
http://www.eda.org/sv-bc/minutes/sv-bc_04_11_30.txt [^]

Version 3 approved non-unanimously Dec. 6, 2004 by SV-BC.

Proposals 2 and 3 non-unanimously reversed by SV-BC on Dec. 6, 2004 and moved back to assigned state.

Fixed in P1800/D3
Tags No tags attached.
Type Errata
Attached Files pdf file icon P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-2.pdf [^] (23,529 bytes) 2004-12-01 07:24
pdf file icon P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-3.pdf [^] (27,413 bytes) 2004-12-06 10:07
pdf file icon P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal.pdf [^] (196,846 bytes) 2004-12-16 23:54
pdf file icon P1800_keyword_compatibility_pragma_proposal.pdf [^] (197,866 bytes) 2004-12-16 23:56
pdf file icon P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-4.pdf [^] (27,441 bytes) 2004-12-21 09:11

- Relationships
related to 0000354closedshalom Add command line switch to control keyword compatibility of input 

-  Notes
User avatar (0000434)
Brad Pierce (developer)
2004-12-06 10:02

 Add version 3.
User avatar (0000435)
Brad Pierce (developer)
2004-12-06 10:30

 Another resolution.
User avatar (0000586)
mmaidment (manager)
2004-12-21 09:18

 Added version 4 which is what was passed in
Dec 20 SV-BC Meeting. Vote was not unanimous:

Opposed: Karen (premature to add feature)
         Surrendra (prefers pragmas)
For: Dan, Mark, Nikhil, Cliff, Stu, Don, Kathy
User avatar (0000626)
Karen Pieper (administrator)
2005-01-05 11:47

 Passed in the 1/5/05 P1800 meeting. -- KLP
User avatar (0000711)
Brad Pierce (developer)
2005-01-25 15:31

 Based on Matt's review reported in http://www.eda.org/sv-bc/hm/2648.html [^]
and the fact that the assignee himself implemented the fix in the LRM, I am moving this erratum to closed as fixed.

- Issue History
Date Modified Username Field Change
2004-11-29 20:27 Brad Pierce New Issue
2004-11-29 20:27 Brad Pierce File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal.pdf
2004-11-29 20:27 Brad Pierce Type => Errata
2004-11-29 20:28 Brad Pierce Assigned To => Stuart Sutherland
2004-11-29 20:28 Brad Pierce Status new => assigned
2004-11-29 20:28 Brad Pierce Category Encryption => SV-BC
2004-11-29 20:30 Brad Pierce Description Updated
2004-11-29 20:31 Brad Pierce Description Updated
2004-12-01 07:24 Brad Pierce File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-2.pdf
2004-12-01 07:25 Brad Pierce File Deleted: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal.pdf
2004-12-01 07:26 Brad Pierce Status assigned => resolved
2004-12-01 07:26 Brad Pierce Resolution open => fixed
2004-12-01 07:26 Brad Pierce Additional Information Updated
2004-12-06 10:02 Brad Pierce Status resolved => feedback
2004-12-06 10:02 Brad Pierce Resolution fixed => reopened
2004-12-06 10:02 Brad Pierce Note Added: 0000434
2004-12-06 10:07 Brad Pierce File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-3.pdf
2004-12-06 10:08 Brad Pierce Status feedback => resolved
2004-12-06 10:08 Brad Pierce Resolution reopened => fixed
2004-12-06 10:08 Brad Pierce Additional Information Updated
2004-12-06 10:30 Brad Pierce Status resolved => feedback
2004-12-06 10:30 Brad Pierce Resolution fixed => reopened
2004-12-06 10:30 Brad Pierce Note Added: 0000435
2004-12-06 10:32 Brad Pierce Status feedback => assigned
2004-12-06 10:32 Brad Pierce Additional Information Updated
2004-12-16 23:54 mmaidment File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal.pdf
2004-12-16 23:56 mmaidment File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_pragma_proposal.pdf
2004-12-21 09:11 mmaidment File Added: P1800_keyword_compatibility_directive_proposal-4.pdf
2004-12-21 09:18 mmaidment Note Added: 0000586
2004-12-21 09:21 mmaidment Status assigned => resolved
2004-12-21 09:21 mmaidment Resolution reopened => fixed
2005-01-05 11:47 Karen Pieper Status resolved => feedback
2005-01-05 11:47 Karen Pieper Resolution fixed => reopened
2005-01-05 11:47 Karen Pieper Note Added: 0000626
2005-01-05 11:47 Karen Pieper Status feedback => assigned
2005-01-05 11:47 Karen Pieper Category SV-BC => SV-LRM
2005-01-10 18:12 Stuart Sutherland Status assigned => completed
2005-01-10 18:12 Stuart Sutherland Additional Information Updated
2005-01-17 10:11 Karen Pieper Category SV-LRM => SV-BC
2005-01-25 15:31 Brad Pierce Note Added: 0000711
2005-01-25 15:31 Brad Pierce Status completed => closed
2005-01-25 15:31 Brad Pierce Resolution reopened => fixed
2007-07-29 01:26 shalom Relationship added related to 0000354

Mantis 1.1.7[^]
Copyright © 2000 - 2008 Mantis Group
Powered by Mantis Bugtracker