| Id |
Category |
Summary |
Resolution |
Duplicate ID |
SV* Vote |
SV* Comment |
Ch Rcmd |
Ch Vote |
Ch Comment |
| 40 |
SV-LRM |
diagram for parameter
is missing |
fixed |
0 |
?? |
|
Close
as already implemented |
Unanimous |
|
| 623 |
SV-BC |
Assignment patterns
should be lvalues |
open |
0 |
1-ABS |
Dave Rich abstained from the vote. He believes that the schedule is
too tight to thoroughly investigate resolution to this issue |
Approve |
Unanimous |
Has
PLI impacts. Issue 717 was opened to
reflect this. |
| 482 |
SV-CC |
32.27 Don't need
vpiBuiltIn property |
fixed |
0 |
1-ABS |
Michael abstained - just joined meeting and did not get to hear
discussion |
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 704 |
V-1364 |
Incorrect
specification of $removal (15.2.4) |
fixed |
0 |
1-ABS |
Stu abstained because he doesn't understand those routines. |
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 694 |
SV-BC |
Ballot Issue 228:
SystemVerilog should include 2-value net datatypes. |
not a bug |
0 |
1-no |
Brad Pierce dissented. He would like to see this feature included in
the LRM. |
Approve |
Unanimous |
Brad
believes that this is a hole that we cannot fix in a week. This is not a showstopper issue. |
| 578 |
SV-BC |
19.8 Default rules
for port kinds do not specify variable case |
open |
0 |
2:ABS |
Abstain:
Mark (Not backward compatible with SV 3.1a)
Karen (came in too late to
discussion) |
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 669 |
V-1364 |
Participant lists for
Introduction |
fixed |
0 |
No Vote Required |
|
Discuss |
Unanimous |
What
format does the working group want, one list or many? |
| 246 |
SV-EC |
Random object
stability example code |
not a bug |
0 |
None |
|
To
EC |
Unanimous |
Vote
not recorded |
| 688 |
V-1364 |
ETF618:
$timeskew/$fullskew issues |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
To
V-1364 |
Unanimous |
Needs
editing changes clearly defined |
| 526 |
SV-CC |
VPI references to
dynamic objects prevent garbage collection |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
To
SV-CC |
Unanimous |
Clarification
of where does the added text go (replace note, precede note), and there is a
NOTE -- that looks like it is normative, change will to shall in the note as
well? |
| 621 |
SV-BC |
Make implicit
continuous assignments illegal in packages |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Close
as duplicate of 633 |
Unanimous |
|
| 620 |
SV-BC |
Add packed unions to
type compatibility rules |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Close
as duplicate of 631 |
Unanimous |
|
| 627 |
SV-BC |
Clarifications on
bind syntax (P1800 ballot comment 202) |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
Does
the comment have to appear on the ballot also |
| 576 |
Encryption |
Annex H descriptions
need revision for clarity |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
FYI. The Champions aren't aware of how
Encryption impacted the VPI. Is a
proposal coming? |
| 324 |
SV-BC |
Add asymmetric casex
statement |
open |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
Has
PLI impacts. Issue 718 was opened to
reflect this. |
| 619 |
SV-BC |
$typeof() should be
as widely usable as any data type |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
May
have PLI impacts, may not because type is evaluated at elaboration time, and
PLI is post elaboration. PLI Issue
opened is 719. This is a backwardly
incompatible change with 3.1a because it removes $typeof |
| 681 |
SV-EC |
Class procedural code
and program interactions |
not a bug |
0 |
Unanimous |
Issue 240 was withdrawn |
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 667 |
V-1364 |
Time 0 order of
evaluation |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 425 |
SV-CC |
29.3.2.1 violates a
principle design feature of VPI |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 692 |
SV-BC |
Assignment-like
context needn't be input |
duplicate |
623 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 629 |
SV-BC |
Hierarchical
references in a modport |
open |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 435 |
SV-CC |
30.2.2.1 Phrase
"has no effect" is ambiguous |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 604 |
SV-CC |
Annex E: routines are
not always declared in instantiable scopes |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 611 |
SV-CC |
Usage of notes in the
Interfaces section |
duplicate |
695 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 596 |
SV-EC |
16.12 Input sampling
description makes no sense |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 622 |
SV-BC |
Delete the keyword
'task' in example |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 505 |
SV-BC |
Verilog compatibility
and interoperability |
open |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 691 |
SV-BC |
Cast compatible port
connections |
not a bug |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 624 |
SV-BC |
upward defparam and
arrayed interface port |
reopened |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 304 |
SV-BC |
$unpacked_dimensions |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 506 |
SV-BC |
package parameters |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 690 |
SV-BC |
Var keyword
unnecessary |
not a bug |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 671 |
SV-EC |
Clocking block race
condition |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 552 |
SV-EC |
Option/type_options
for covergroup not in the Annex A |
not a bug |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 411 |
SV-EC |
Problem with default
arguments |
duplicate |
642 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 605 |
SV-CC |
32.2 & 32.3 &
32.6 vpiDefaultClocking is not in include file |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 415 |
V-PTF |
26.6.3 improperly
drawn diagram - regression |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 683 |
SV-EC |
Return values of
semaphore and mailbox functions |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 662 |
SV-EC |
Confusing text
regarding dynamic dimensions |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 93 |
SV-EC |
SV-BC Issue 5: 1038
Optional argument list for subroutine calls |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 548 |
SV-BC |
19.11.3, 19.11.4 Do
package references get connected in implicit name and * port connections |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 513 |
SV-BC |
inconsistency of port
connection rules 19.11.2, 19.11.3, 19.11.4 |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 682 |
SV-BC |
Initialization --
STU1 |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
| 577 |
Encryption |
Clause 28: replace
"should" with more appropriate text |
fixed |
0 |
Unanimous |
|
Approve |
Unanimous |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|