Re: Priority, Disposition, and Grouping of remaining issues

Erich,

Concerning issue 39 (input sampling mechanism).

This issue arrived after the original assignment of priorities,
and was allocated by the issues subcommittee to extensions.
It hasn't yet been given a group.

In a couple of recent mails, I've suggested that there are
a number of related points:
- sampling policy (as raised in both issues 39 and 22)
- definition of model associated with a synthesized netlist
- semantics of vunit linked to a design

I propose that these be considered as a group, either as
issue 39, or split into more than one issue. I believe that
a decision on the definition of the model associated with
a synthesized netlist leads to a decision on the other two
points.

Recent discussions on these points indicate that there is
enough interest in them to merit full discussion in the
extensions subcommittee. Issue 22 was in fact rejected in
the original disposition. But I believe the detailed
voting demonstrates a significant level of interest among
the organizations represented, including two 4 or 5 priorities.

Regards,

Anthony

Erich Marschner wrote:
>
> Issues Subcommittee participants,
>
> Now that the issues list is updated, we need to finish the prioritization and disposition of the remaining issues. Please review the issues list at http://www.eda.org/ieee-1850/Issues/Issues.html and decide what we should do about the following:
>
> - priorities (5..1, or 0 for Reject) for Issues 37-50
> - disposition (L,E,R,OOS) for Issues 45-50
> - groupings for remaining ungrouped issues (new groups, or additions to existing groups)
>
> Please post your opinions about the above to the ieee-1850-issues reflector, preferably by 8amPST Tuesday, so we can consider them in the Extensions SC meeting following the WG meeting.
>
> Regards,
>
> Erich

-- 
Anthony McIsaac
STMicroelectronics (R&D) Limited
1000 Aztec West
Almondsbury
Bristol BS32 4SQ
Tel: ++44 (0)1454 462466
Fax: ++44 (0)1454 462305
Email: Anthony.McIsaac@st.com